Home Blog
Services

Our Services

A neutral expertise for every step of your technological maturity, from crisis management to strategic planning.
IT Audit
IT Audit
IT Audit
IT Budget Audit
IT Budget Audit
IT Budget Audit
vCIO
vCIO
vCIO
Counter-Expertise
Counter-Expertise
Counter-Expertise
Backup Test
Backup Test
Backup Test
Discover all our services
ContactSchedule a call
Français
HomeBlogServicesContactSchedule a call
Français

Independent IT Second Opinion — Before You Sign, Get It Checked

Counter-expertise for IT quotes, plans, and recommendations — clear answer: go, no-go, or go with conditions.

IT counter-expertise is an independent opinion on a quote, recommendation, or technology proposal you've received. Factero analyzes the document, verifies technical and financial coherence, and gives you a 100% neutral opinion — with no ties to the vendor being evaluated. When something feels off about what you've been proposed, counter-expertise is exactly what you need.
Talk to an expert

Who is it for?

GMs, CFOs or boards receiving a significant IT quote.

Organizations wanting to validate a modernization plan.

Parties involved in litigation requiring independent technical analysis.

Internal IT directors who want external validation before presenting a plan to their leadership.

Internal IT teams who want to validate their own recommendations before presenting them to leadership.

When does it help?

If you recognize yourself in any of these situations, this service is designed for you.
  • A provider presents a significant quote and you want a neutral second opinion before signing.
  • An architecture was designed internally or by an integrator, and you want to validate it holds up.
  • A modernization plan is on the table, but nobody in-house has the expertise to challenge the assumptions.
  • A document seems questionable and you need an independent analysis.

What will you receive?

Checkbox icon

A clear opinion: go, no-go, or go with conditions.

Checkbox icon

The analysis of identified assumptions and risks.

Checkbox icon

Concrete recommendations if adjustments are needed.

Checkbox icon

Format adapted to the scope of the mandate: structured verbal assessment for a standard quote analysis (2h format); full written report for an architecture, modernization plan, or multi-component file.

Checkbox icon

Delivery timeline: a few business days for a standard quote; one to two weeks for an architecture or multi-phase plan. Specified in the proposal based on document complexity.

Not a good fit?

  • If you're looking for a quick validation on a specific question — a quote to skim, a doubt to clear up in two hours — the SME offer is probably the right starting point. A counter-expertise is different: it's an in-depth analysis of a document that deserves careful attention — a migration proposal, a network architecture, a transformation plan, a contract with complex technical clauses. Situations where assumptions are numerous, stakes are real, and you need to understand what you're signing or approving. Our assessment can very well support a decision you've already made — and in many cases, it confirms it. But it will always be honest and non-compliant. If we see something that doesn't add up, we'll tell you — that's precisely what gives the assessment its value. All our mandates are covered by a confidentiality agreement. What you share with us stays between us.

How does the process work?

A rigorous and transparent approach, step by step.
Proposal analysis
We analyze the proposal from the perspective of your objectives and constraints.
Assumptions verification
We verify assumptions. We identify what's solid and what isn't.
Clear opinion
We give you a clear verdict: go, no-go, or go with conditions. With concrete recommendations if adjustments are needed. If you'd like, we can also engage directly with your provider to clarify technical points before concluding.

Frequently Asked Questions

Answers to the questions our clients ask before reaching out.
Will you talk to our provider?
Only if you explicitly ask us to. Factero's counter-expertise is an independent exercise — by default, we analyze the proposal or quote based on the documentation provided and our market knowledge, without contacting the provider. However, in some cases, a direct exchange with the provider helps clarify ambiguous points, obtain technical details not in the document, or validate sizing assumptions. If you wish, we can initiate this exchange collaboratively — the goal isn't confrontation, but having the right information to give you the most complete and useful assessment possible. In all cases, you control the process and decide what is shared with whom.
What's your approach to analyzing a quote or plan?
The analysis starts from your objectives and constraints — not the document itself. Factero first verifies whether the provider's assumptions are realistic, documented, and consistent with your operational reality. We then evaluate the technical sizing (too much, too little, or just right), the pricing relative to market rates, and the risks not mentioned in the proposal. The analysis draws on recognized reference frameworks — NIST-CSF for risk assessment, COBIT for governance, ISO 27001 for security components — depending on what's relevant to the document being evaluated. The principal associate holds the CISA certification (Certified Information Systems Auditor) from ISACA. The final assessment is structured in three sections: what's solid and can be accepted as-is, what's risky and deserves discussion, and what we recommend modifying or clarifying before signing.
How long does a counter-expertise take?
For a standard quote or proposal, a counter-expertise typically takes a few days to two weeks. The exact timeline depends on the technical complexity of the document, the volume of documentation to analyze, and the number of areas covered (infrastructure, security, budget, licensing). For a complete architecture or detailed modernization plan involving multiple providers, the timeline can extend to three or four weeks. Factero provides a precise estimate when defining the mandate scope, and we stick to it. If an urgent decision requires a quick opinion on a specific aspect — for example validating a quote before a signature deadline — we can propose a reduced scope with an accelerated timeline. A free 20-minute discovery call helps define the scope and estimate the timeline for your situation.
Our internal IT director designed the plan we want reviewed. How do we handle that?
This is a common situation, and it's handled constructively. Factero's role isn't to evaluate the person's competence — it's to validate the plan on its technical merits and alignment with your business objectives, budget, and operational constraints. We involve the IT director in the process: they know the context better than anyone, and their input is valuable for understanding the trade-offs they had to make. The result may confirm the solidity of their work (giving them useful external validation to present to leadership), suggest targeted adjustments, or identify blind spots nobody had seen — including the IT director themselves. In all cases, the exercise is perceived as reinforcement, not as questioning. An independent external perspective protects everyone.
On what basis do you evaluate a proposal?
Factero analyzes each proposal along three axes: your actual objectives, your budget, and your operational constraints. We don't start from the provider's document — we start from your business reality to evaluate whether what's proposed adequately addresses it. The evaluation draws on recognized industry frameworks: NIST-CSF for risk and security aspects, COBIT for governance and strategic alignment, ISO 27001 for information security. We also verify pricing relative to the Quebec and Canadian market for your type of organization. The principal associate holds the CISA certification (Certified Information Systems Auditor) from ISACA. The final assessment is structured, factual, and documented — with actionable recommendations, not general impressions. Each finding is accompanied by a technical justification and a clear recommendation.
Our advice is 100% neutral and independent. See our Charter of Independence.

Related services

IT Audit Provider Relationship Management Expert Witness See more

Need to move forward on this?

Let's discuss your specific situation. No commitment, just expert advice.
Talk to an expert